Best Cars for Retirees on a Budget: Avoid These Costly Models

Few expenses can drain Social Security benefits as quickly as unexpected repair costs from an unreliable vehicle, high depreciation rates, or a steep purchase price. These are just a few reasons why retirees on a fixed budget should avoid certain vehicles if they don't want their golden years burdened by financial strain.

According to the Social Security Administration, the average monthly benefit for a retired worker is approximately $2,071. As such, there are certain cars that seniors should simply steer clear of to make the most of what they live on. Which are worth avoiding? These 10 vehicles could potentially endanger your retirement savings.

Smart Drivers, Smarter Savings.

Compare car insurance rates in Missouri

See if lower rates are available

Currently Insured?

Yes

No

By clicking the button above, I understand and agree that this site uses site visit recording technology (provided by Trusted Form, Jornaya, and Microsoft Clarity) Privacy Policy

2023 GMC Arcadia

Khairil/Adobe

Average Price: $29,866

Retirees in the market for a reliable three-row SUV should steer clear of the 2023 GMC Arcadia. According to RepairPal, this hulking SUV is near the bottom of its segment in terms of reliability. They rank it as one of the most unreliable midsize SUVs on the market.

While the average midsize SUV has average annual repair costs of $485, the 2023 GMC Arcadia has average annual repair costs of $610.

2025 Chevrolet Blazer EV

jetcityimage/Adobe

Average Price: $35,262

Owners themselves have complained about issues with the 2025 Chevrolet Blazer EV's technology. They've had problems with the infotainment screen freezing and numerous issues with its music system. They also experienced service delays trying to get these issues fixed and had challenges charging the vehicle.

Plus, reviewers have criticized this EV for offering lackluster value given its high starting price compared to other electric SUVs. With options added on, the electric SUV costs nearly as much as a Cadillac, but it's still just a Chevy.

2025 Jeep Gladiator

jetcityimage/Adobe

Average Price: $44,111

The 2025 Jeep Gladiator has been criticized for offering poor value to consumers. According to Edmunds, virtually every other truck in the midsize segment will offer superior standard features and better driving aids. It's also a vehicle that is heavily focused on off-roading, limiting its practicality as a daily driver.

Additionally, it's quite a gas guzzler, which isn't ideal for someone living on a strict budget. Retirees in the market for a midsize truck that can serve them well on any terrain should look elsewhere.

2022 Tesla Model S

UnPinky/Adobe

Average Price: $48,478

The 2022 Tesla Model S will cost retirees a whopping $823 a year on unscheduled repairs and maintenance, according to RepairPal. That's almost half of the average Social Security check.

Reviewers have also knocked this EV for having questionable build quality, such as incorrect alignment of the driver's door and obviously crooked trim pieces in its interior. Between its shoddy build quality and outrageous repair costs, retirees on a fixed budget should pass on this EV.

2022 Polestar 2

sue/Adobe

Average Price: $22,703

Edmunds warns that the 2022 Polestar 2 lacks the established support infrastructure of more developed automotive brands with clear track records. Long-term, trying to get issues for this sporty EV addressed could be challenging, especially for budget-conscious seniors and retirees with limited finances.

Owners have regretted driving this vehicle due to issues with its performance in very hot or very cold conditions. Some cited issues with the AC not working when it was hot in the summer, while others cited its dismal driving range in the cold winter months. Overall, it may not be worth the hassle.

2024 Honda Prologue

jetcityimage/Adobe

Average Price: $25,637

Many 2024 Honda Prologue owners have noted issues with braking, dismal charging speeds, and unreliable technology. They also complained about unsatisfactory service and support from Honda when trying to address these issues. Not exactly what you want when spending over $25,000.

Overall, reviewers have cited rival electric SUVs as better purchases for consumers.

2024 Chrysler Pacifica Plug-in Hybrid

jetcityimage/Adobe

Average Price: $28,497

Owners have complained about the 2024 Chrysler Pacifica Plug-in Hybrid suffering from a multitude of technology issues. They've cited problems with its touchscreens, Bluetooth capabilities, and have found a lot of its modern features to be prone to errors.

Some have also noted issues with the door locks and transmission problems. Between the likelihood of unwanted repair costs and potential safety issues, retirees looking for a safe, reliable family vehicle should pass on this one.

2025 Nissan Rogue

jetcityimage/Adobe

Average Price: $22,663

Drivers have reported numerous issues with the 2025 Nissan Rogue's infotainment system, including its screen going blank, as well as consistently unreliable electronics and difficulty getting them fixed. They have also reported having to deal with frustrating engine issues, which may be unsettling for senior drivers.

2024 Kia EV6

artographer34/Adobe

Average Price: $27,779

The 2024 Kia EV6 has been known to suffer from a variety of issues, including complicated controls, inconsistent charging, and poor customer service from the automaker. This could be an issue for older drivers.

Additionally, some owners have stated that the vehicle was expensive to insure and had issues performing in inclement weather, such as snow. Retirees looking to make the most of their Social Security payments probably don't want to spend their time or money stressing over the vehicle.

2025 BMW X5 Plug-in Hybrid

adinamnt/Adobe

Average Price: $63,713

The 2025 BMW X5 Plug-in Hybrid is yet another EV/hybrid SUV that owners have serious issues with. Not only is it incredibly expensive, but drivers have reported engine problems, complicated technology, long repair times, and poor customer service when dealing with BMW.

Additionally, RepairPal reports that the probability that a repair will be a major issue in a 2025 BMW X5 Plug-in Hybrid is 17.8%, which is more than the average luxury fullsize SUV.

Bottom line

Chandlerlikes/Adobe

According to CarGurus, the average price of a used vehicle sits at $27,901. Anyone on a fixed budget looking to enjoy a stress-free retirement should avoid unreliable vehicles given a price like that.

EVs and hybrid vehicles are particularly problematic in this regard because the average cost of an EV battery replacement can range from $4,000-$18,000. That's certainly not an expense that anyone wants to spend their hard-earned retirement savings on.

We can help boost your earning potential even further!

Loading...

Confirming Subscription

Loading...

Thanks for Becoming an EXTRA Ultimate Subscriber!

Check your texts

Reminder: Check your inbox as well to confirm your EXTRA email subscription.